Survey
* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
Roots of Progressivism The Progressive Era The period from about 1890 to 1920 when many believed a solution to social problems in the nation lay in a more active role by the government • Working conditions, rights for women and children, economic reform, government corruption, environmental issues and social welfare were a few of these issues. Key Characteristics 1) Government should play an active role in solving society’s problems 2) Government needed to be more efficient 3) New inventions and new cures (improvements in science) can help society 4) The people should have more say in their government 5) Women should have the right to vote Progressives believed that by applying scientific principals to solving social problems, the result would be new inventions and innovations that would improve the lives of everyone. MUCKRAKERS • Young reporters who “dug deep for the dirt that the public loved to hate”. • Teddy Roosevelt accused them of raking up muck through his writings. • Muckraking Magazines: -McClure’s -Cosmopolitan -Collier’s -Everybody’s Muckrakers Journalists who practiced what today is called "investigative journalism" in order to spotlight corruption in society Jacob Riis Upton Sinclair Ida Tarbell The Social Gospel • The outrage of social and economic injustice brought on a humanitarian sense of social responsibility. • Historian Paul Boyer says, "many Christians came to believe that through reform efforts, through reform legislation dealing with child labor, with slums and tenement houses and unsafe working conditions, human beings really could build the Kingdom of God on earth." William Jennings Bryan carried this idea into his three presidential campaigns (1896, 1900, 1908). • http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/amex/monkeytrial/peopleevent s/e_gospel.html • Disagreeing with the Social Darwinists progressives argued that ignorance, poverty, even criminality were the result of unhealthy environment. • Settlement Homes • Brought on the field of social work • http://www.uic.edu/jaddams/ hull/_learn/_aboutjane/abo utjane.html • YMCA • Salvation Army Jane Addams opened the Hull House in Chicago. PROMOTE MORAL DEVELOPMENT • Some reformers felt that the answer to societies problems was personal behavior • They proposed such reforms as prohibition • Groups wishing to ban alcohol included the Woman’s Christian Temperance Union (WCTU) • 18th Amendment 1919 • http://www.pbs.org/kenburn s/prohibition/roots-ofprohibition/ Carrie A Nation • http://www.pbs.o rg/wgbh/amex/19 00/peopleevents/ pande4.html Jacob Riis Journalist whose book “How the Other Half Lives” led to calls for government assistance to help the urban poor His books gave a vivid look at the life for ethnic groups of New York City living in the tenement slums New York City tenement buildings in the early 1900s Upton Sinclair’s The Jungle In 1906, Upton Sinclair wrote The Jungle to describe the conditions in the meatpacking industry Sinclair wanted to highlight the plight of the working class Instead, the book raised fears of what was in the meat that people were eating Impact of The Jungle Meat Inspection Act Required federal inspection of meat and required the Agricultural Department (USDA) to set standards of cleanliness in meatpacking plants Pure Food and Drug Act Banned the sale of impure or falsely labeled food or drugs Ida Tarbell • One of the leading "muckrakers" of her day • Wrote many notable magazine series and biographies. • Best-known for her 1904 book “The History of the Standard Oil Company” Efficient Governments During the Progressive Era, reformers wanted to rid city government of political influence and make local government more efficient Grand Prairie’s city management team To do so, many city’s hired an outside expert to manage the city. This person was called a city manager A More Democratic Union During the Progressive Era, many reformers felt the people needed to have more control of the government Politicians like Wisconsin Governor Robert Lafollette, above, wanted to get power out of the hands of party leaders and into the hands of the people The Direct Primary The direct primary gave voters power to choose the candidates in an election. This reform led to Wisconsin becoming known as the “laboratory of democracy” Other voting changes brought on by Progressives included the initiative, the referendum and the recall Initiative and Referendum Allows a group of citizens to introduce legislation (a law) in their state government and require the legislature to vote on it Allows proposed legislation (a law) to be voted on directly by the people instead of just its state legislature • 1905; John H. Mitchell (ROR). Charge: Corruption. Result: Not Expelled. Note: Mitchell died on December 8, while his case was still on appeal and before the Senate. • 1906; Joseph R. Burton (RKS). Charge: Corruption. Result: Resigned. Note: Burton was indicted and convicted of receiving compensation for intervening with a federal agency. When the Supreme Court upheld his conviction, he resigned rather than face expulsion th The 17 Amendment In 1913, Congress amended the U.S. Constitution. Senators were now to be chosen by a direct election of the people of a state, not by the state governments. • TR did support a few individuals such as Booker T. Washington. “Put down your bucket and work for immediate self-improvement.” Birth of the N.A.A.C.P. One issue the Progressive Movement did not address was the issue of equal rights African Americans. In response, W.E.B. Dubois helped to form the NAACP in 1909 NAACP FORMED TO PROMOTE RIGHTS 1964 Application • 1909 National Association for the Advancement of Colored People • The NAACP had 6,000 members by 1914 • The means to achieve this was the court system • The NAACP's principal objective is to ensure the political, educational, social and economic equality of minority group citizens of United States and eliminate race prejudice. William Edward Burghardt DuBois • The first African-American to earn a PhD from Harvard University. • Professor at Atlanta University. • He became the head of the NAACP in 1910 • Founder and editor of the NAACP's journal The Crisis. • Du Bios rose to national attention in his opposition of Booker T. Washington’s ideas of social integration between whites and blacks, campaigning instead for increased political representation for blacks in order to guarantee civil rights, and the formation of a Black elite that would work for the progress of the African American race Temperance Movement Some progressives believed that a lot of the nation’s problems were tied in with the consumption and sale of alcohol The movement to rid the nation of alcohol was known as the temperance movement. Three groups led the call for temperance: women’s groups, business owners and Christians Temperance Movement The leader of the movement was an hatchet wielding woman by the name of Carrie Nation Women led the call for temperance because alcoholism led to abusive men and loss of jobs th 18 Amendment passed The 18th Amendment made the sale or consumption of alcohol illegal throughout the United States th 18 Amendment passed Election of 1900 In the presidential election of 1900, President William McKinley choose as his vice-presidential candidate someone who was a hero from the Spanish-American War, someone who had strong ties to the Northeast (New York), and someone who was a Progressive – Theodore Roosevelt Roosevelt takes over McKinley was assassinated in 1901 Teddy Roosevelt – at the age of 42 – suddenly became the youngest president in U.S. history THE MODERN PRESIDENT • When Roosevelt was thrust into the presidency in 1901, he became the youngest president ever at age 42 • He quickly established himself as a modern president who could influence the media and shape legislation Teddy Roosevelt as President • Brought Dynamic energy to Presidency. • “Bully Pulpit.” According to the "Oxford English Dictionary," bully pulpit means "a public office or position of authority that provides its occupant with an outstanding opportunity to speak out on any issue." It was first used by TR, explaining his view of the presidency, in this quotation -- "I suppose my critics will call that preaching, but I have got such a bully pulpit!" The word bully itself was an adjective in the vernacular of the time meaning "first- rate," somewhat equivalent to the recent use of the word "awesome." The term "bully pulpit" is still used today to describe the president's power to influence the public. Roosevelt’s “Square Deal” Teddy Roosevelt was a progressive president Roosevelt pushed through laws to: 1) break up big business monopolies (trusts) 2) protect the environment and public health 3) improve working conditions for factory workers SQUARE DEAL • Control of corporations • Consumer protection • Conservation of natural resources TR believed in regulating not fragmenting big business. Roosevelt: The Trustbuster Roosevelt saw the need for government to regulate large corporations While he believed that large corporations were an important part of the nation’s prosperity, he also believed that these corporations were hurting workers TRUSTBUSTING • By 1900, Trusts – legal bodies created to hold stock in many companies – controlled 80% of U.S. industries • Roosevelt filed 44 antitrust suits under the Sherman Antitrust Act Northern Securities v. the U.S. Roosevelt and the government sued Northern Securities, a trust made up of two large railroads The Supreme Court rules that Northern Securities was a monopoly and in violation of the Sherman Antitrust Act Northern Securities v. the U.S. The case set the precedent for declaring a trust unconstitutional and against the law The victory was important because it: • Established Roosevelt as a “trust-buster” • Increased the power of the presidency • Showed the executive branch was even more powerful than the nation's most powerful business institutions. T.R. and Conservation Roosevelt put his stamp on the presidency most clearly in the area of environmental conservation Roosevelt declared millions of acres of land as protected national forests and urged Americans to conserve their natural resources T.R. and Conservation Authorized by Teddy Roosevelt 150 national forests 51 federal bird reserves 4 national game preserves 5 national parks 18 national monuments 24 reclamation projects -the conversion of desert, marsh, or other waste land into land suitable for cultivation http://www.pbs.org/nationalparks/history/ep2/ National Parks started by Teddy Roosevelt Newlands Reclamation Act Roosevelt secures passage of the Newlands Reclamation Act, funded irrigation projects for the arid lands of 20 states in the American west funded by public land sales. Bureau of Reclamation Established in 1902 Constructed dams, power plants, and canals in 17 western states Sells water wholesale Provides irrigation to the farmland that produces 60 percent of the vegetables in the U.S. 58 power plants provide electricity to six million homes Anthracite Coal Strike of 1902 Roosevelt felt that one of his jobs was to stop job conflicts between different groups in the nation When the United Mine Workers went on strike in 1902, Roosevelt intervened in the strike and got the union and the owners to agree to arbitration Hepburn Act of 1906 Roosevelt wanted the government to be able to regulate railroad rates to insure fairness The Hepburn Act gave the Interstate Commerce Commission the power to set railroad rates to make sure that companies did not compete unfairly with each other Progressivism under Taft and Wilson Taft Takes Over Teddy Roosevelt did not run for President in 1908. Instead, he hand-picked his successor in tabbing William Howard Taft. PROGRESSIVISM UNDER PRESIDENT TAFT • Republican William Howard Taft easily defeated Democrat William Jennings Bryan to win the 1908 presidential election Taft, right, was Roosevelt’s War Secretary Taft defeats William Jennings Bryan Problems with Taft Although he was handpicked by TR, Taft was not popular with Progressives Taft was not the politician that Roosevelt was and lacked the energy and personal magnetism of his mentor Payne-Aldrich Tariff The Payne-Aldrich Tariff Act was the law that called for lower tariff (taxes on imports) The tariff was suppose to provide American industrialists with cheap raw materials Because of compromises in Congress, it did not CONTROVERSIES • Payne-Aldrich Tariff (didn’t cut tariffs enough, angered progressives) • Replaced Sec of Interior James R. Garfield with a lawyer (R. Ballinger) that tried to sell govt protected land. Chief Forester Gifford Pinchot leaked the information and Taft fired Pinchot for insubordination. Taft’s accomplishments • Children’s Bureau 1912 (Under the US Health and Human Services today). • Mann-Elkins Act (1910) – once again increased the power of the ICC • Busted up Standard Oil and filed suit against US Steel(against Teddy’s wishes) Roosevelt challenges Taft Split Between TR and Taft • TR angry with Taft’s actions. • Believes that only HE (TR) can unify the Republican party. William Henry Harrison Ulysses S. Grant Rutherford B. Hayes James A Garfield Benjamin Harrison William McKinley William Howard Taft Warren Harding New Nationalism Speech • Speech by TR in Osawatomie, Kansas 1910. • Most radical of career. • Says that the federal govt. has the responsibility to protect the social welfare of the citizens. • Calls for income and inheritance taxes, workmen’s comp., minimum wage and minimum hours, etc. The first federal minimum-wage law, the Fair Labor Standards Act, passed in 1938, with a 25-cent-per-hour wage floor and a 44hour workweek ceiling for most employees. The Republican Convention • Republicans were divided over who to support—TR or Taft. • Taft eventually got the Republican nomination. • TR decided to run anyway and organized the Progressive (or “Bull Moose”) Party. http://query.nytimes.com/mem/archivefree/pdf?res=990CE7DC1E3AE733A2575AC1A9609C946496D6CF T.R. and the Bull Moose Party Upset with the direction that Taft had taken the country, in 1912 Roosevelt ran for an unprecedented third term as President. When it became clear that the Republican party was not going to nominate him, TR left the convention and formed the Progressive Party, also known as the Bull Moose Party. The Democrats • They Pick Woodrow Wilson • He had been a history professor and then President of Princeton University. • He was a Progressive governor of New Jersey. • The Panic of 1893 prompted some Americans to question the capitalist economic system • As a result some workers embraced socialism • Eugene Debs organized the American Socialist Party in 1901 – Though most progressives did not embrace socialism, many writers saw the truth in Debs’ criticism Debs encouraged workers to reject American Capitalism Eugene Debs and Socialists Debs ran for president 4 times; he received over 1 million votes in 1912 Debs believed the role of the government was to protect the workers from greedy business owners. To do this, the government needed to take control of big business. Lafollette and Progressives Lafollette made his first run for president in 1912, running as a Progressive. He would run again in 1924. Lafollette lost the nomination to Teddy Roosevelt in 1912 and ran in 1924 as the Labor Party Election of 1912 William Howard Taft Republican Woodrow Wilson Democrat Teddy Roosevelt Progressive Eugene V. Debs Socialist The split between the Republicans opened the door for the Democratic candidate – Woodrow Wilson – to win the election. Election of 1912 WILSON’S NEW FREEDOM W. Wilson U.S. President 19121920 • As America’s newly elected president, Wilson moved to enact his program, the “New Freedom” • He planned his attack on what he called the triple wall of privilege: trusts, tariffs, and high finance The Big difference between TR and Wilson • TR advocated regulation as the way to deal with the trusts. “New Nationalism” • Wilson called for breaking-up the trusts to restore competition. “New Freedom” Underwood Tariff • • • • • Passed in 1914 Established Income Tax 1% up to $20,000 7% for incomes above $500,000 Cut tariff rate by the largest percentage in decades The first major reduction in tariffs. The average tariffs was decreased from 41 percent to 27 percent. To replace the lost income, a graduated income tax was imposed. th 16 Amendment The 16th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution created a national income tax. It gave the federal government the power to directly tax its citizens. Federal Reserve Act During those times, many people lost their savings when small banks collapsed and closed, taking people’s savings along with them. To restore people’s confidence in banks, Wilson created the Federal Reserve system. Under this system, banks would keep a portion of their deposits in a regional reserve bank as a cushion in case of a crisis. Federal Reserve Board –Interest rate –Cash in circulation –Requires banks to deposit portion of their money Federal Trade Commission Wilson also wanted to restore competition in the economy. He wanted to break up monopolies. However, once he became president, Wilson realized it would unrealistic to be break up large companies. In 1914, Wilson asked Congress to create the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) to regulate American business. FEDERAL TRADE COMMISSION FORMED Today the FTC has been working on protecting consumers from ID theft • The FTC was formed in 1914 to serve as a “watchdog” agency to end unfair business practices • The FTC protects consumers from business fraud Clayton Antitrust Act To strengthen the federal government’s ability to break up trusts, the Clayton Antitrust Act was passed The law gave unions significantly more power because it legalized unions, strikes, boycotts and pickets What Wilson was against • At first, Wilson refused to support: – – – – Child Labor laws Women’s Suffrage Bills that sought to restrict immigration. Allowed segregation to take place in govt. – When he had to run for re-election, however, he changed and was for: workers comp., child labor laws, and 8-hour workday for railroad workers. Louis Brandeis In reality, Wilson’s policies reflected more of TR’s “New Nationalism” than they did the rhetoric of his “New Freedom.” Wilson also named the ultraliberal Louis Brandeis to the Supreme Court. First Jewish SC justice. PROTECTING WORKING CHILDREN • As the number of child workers rose, reformers worked to end child labor • John Spargo(1906)~The Bitter Cry of the Children-abuses of child labor Keating-Owen Child Labor Act of 1916 • Prohibits the sale and interstate commerce of goods manufactured by underage children, thus giving an expanded importance to the constitutional clause giving Congress the task of regulating interstate commerce. Fight for Women’s Suffrage The fight for women’s voting rights (suffrage) began in the mid-1800s at the Seneca Falls Convention By the 1900s, the leader of the suffrage movement was Susan B. Anthony, left Women’s Suffrage Anthony , a Quaker, organized numerous marches and gave numerous speeches in the fight for suffrage THREE-PART STRATEGY FOR WINNING SUFFRAGE • Suffragists tried three approaches to winning the vote • 1) Convince state legislatures to adopt vote (Succeeded in Wyoming, Utah, Idaho, Colorado) • 2) Pursue court cases to test 14th Amendment • 3) Push for national constitutional Amendment Women’s Suffrage in U.S. (1915) Alice Paul’s influence Following Susan B. Anthony’s death in 1906, radical suffragists formed the National Women’s Party The group, led by Alice Paul, protested the president to get laws changed th 19 Amendment Passed In 1919, the Senate passed the 19th Amendment to the Constitution, granting women the right to vote. It was ratified by the states in 1920 Progressive Foreign Policy TR & “Big Stick” Diplomacy • “Speak softly, and carry a big stick.” • Called for military buildup. • ESPECIALLY THE NAVY. TR and Japan • In 1905, Russia and Japan were at war over control of the northern part of China. • TR mediated a peace agreement that ended the RussoJapanese War. (Nobel Peace Prize) • In 1906, Japan was angry over California’s segregationist policies towards Japanese. • TR solved the problem with a “gentlemen’s agreement” in which the segregationist policies were withdrawn, while Japan agreed to limit its immigration. http://www.history.com/topics/gentlemens-agreement The Great White Fleet • To show the world (& Japan) America’s new naval muscle, TR called for 16 new battleships (all painted white) to make a world tour. (To impress upon Japan that the US Navy could shift from the Atlantic to the Pacific) • The fourteen-month long voyage was a grand pageant of American sea power. The squadrons were manned by 14,000 sailors. They covered some 43,000 miles and made twenty port calls on six continents. Route of Great White Fleet TR’s Beliefs • Big believer in AngloSaxon supremacy. • But also makes distinction between “developed” and “nondeveloped.” Venezuela 1902 • Venezuela was behind on debt payments to Britain, Italy, and Germany. • Blockades began with rumors that Germany was planning to make a permanent base. • Roosevelt steps in and issues his Roosevelt Corollary in 1904. The US has the right to oppose European intervention in the Western Hemisphere as well intervene on their behalf if they could not maintain order. The Roosevelt Corollary • The Monroe Doctrine told Europeans to stay out of the Americas (North, Central, & South). • The Roosevelt Corollary stated that the US would intervene in Central and South America to maintain order. • December 1904 stated that the United States would intervene as a last resort to ensure that other nations in the Western Hemisphere fulfilled their obligations to international creditors, and did not violate the rights of the United States or invite "foreign aggression to the detriment of the entire body of American nations." As the corollary worked out in practice, the United States increasingly used military force to restore internal stability to nations in the region. Roosevelt declared that the United States might "exercise international police power in 'flagrant cases of such wrongdoing or impotence.'" http://history.state.gov/milestones/18991913/RooseveltandMonroeDoctrine Dominican Republic • Revolution had toppled the corrupt and bankrupt government in 1903. • Under pressure from Roosevelt, the Dominicans requested U.S. assistance. Using the RC the US took over the Dominican Republic’s customs, distributing half to the country and half to their foreign creditors. http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/americanexperience/ features/general-article/tr-foreign/ • Three decades Cuba • 1902 under the Platt amendment they were given limited freedom. • 1906 domestic uprisings caused TR to send troops there for 3 years. Cuban President Palma asks Roosevelt to send American troops to Cuba to quell a rebellion which arose from a disputed election. http://millercenter.org/president/keyevents/roosev elt Panama Canal – TR’s biggest accomplishment! TR and the Caribbean • Frequently sent troops into Central America and the Caribbean to restore order and protect American investments. • The Panama Canal (1903). The Panama Canal • Step 1: Hay-Pauncefote Treaty canceled 1850 pact that US and Britain would build a canal together • Step 2: Choose a site. 1st thought Nicaragua because it would be easier at sea level, but instead turned to the isthmus of Panama in Columbia. 40% complete and abandoned by the French. The French lowered their price from $109 million to $40 million. • Step 3: Sec of State John Hay makes a deal with Colombia for the canal zone ($10 million and $250,000 year rent). Colombian senate refuses to ratify and asks for $20 million. • In the New York Journal, William Randolph Hearst opined that "the only way we could secure a satisfactory concession from Colombia would be to go down there, take the contending statesmen by the necks, and hold a batch of them in office long enough to get a contract in mind." Hearst's statement proved prophetic. http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/americanexperience/features/general -article/tr-panama/ • TR refers to the Colombians as “inefficient bandits” and “blackmailers.” Philippe Banua-Varilla (chief engineer of the French project) agrees to help TR by organizing and financing a revolution in Panama!! • TR sends the USS Nashville to help “maintain order.” • 3 days later the US recognizes Panama as a nation and Panama grants the US the canal zone for $10 million and $250,000 rent. “I took the canal zone and let Congress debate and while the debate goes on, the canal zone does too." • Canal opens in 1914 • In 1977, U.S. President Jimmy Carter signed a treaty which agreed to return 60% of the Canal Zone to Panama in 1979. The canal and remaining territory, known as the Canal Area, was returned to Panama at noon (local Panama time) on December 31, 1999 Taft and Dollar Diplomacy • When Taft succeeded TR, he called for a foreign policy in Central America and the Caribbean that emphasized US investment rather than muscle. • Taft used government officials to promote the sale of American products overseas, particularly heavy industrial goods and military hardware. In Taft's conception of foreign policy, the U.S. military was a tool of economic diplomacy. • http://millercenter.org/presiden t/taft/essays/biography/5 Nicaragua • 1909 Taft favored insurgents in a revolution, who were inspired to revolt by an American mining company. • American troops seized custom houses and Taft encouraged banks to make loans to the new government. • 2 years later another revolution broke out, Taft sent troops that stayed for more than an decade. • When Taft ordered two thousand troops to the Mexican border to stand ready to intervene in revolutionary-torn Mexico to protect U.S. investments, Congress offered stiff opposition. Taft then backed off (earning the nickname "Peaceful Bill"), leaving the situation in Mexico for his successor to handle. • A primary focus of dollar diplomacy was the Manchurian region of China. Japan and Russia controlled a large portion of Manchurian resources including the railroads. Taft, like many people of the era, believed that whoever controlled the railroads also controlled the economy. He believed that without an interest in the Manchurian railroad system, the U.S. would be frozen out of the emerging Chinese markets and the United States’ “open door” policy in China would be undermined. Taft personally sent a telegram to the Chinese Government on behalf of American investors interested in railroads in the Yangtze Valley. In 1909, Secretary of State Philander C. Knox offered the Japanese and Russians a deal. He proposed that American bankers and industrialists would purchase the Manchurian railroads from Japan and Russia and return them to Chinese control. Japan and Russia flatly refused the offer, which publicly embarrassed the Taft administration. Taft persevered in his efforts to gain influence in China, and in 1912 the U.S. and five other nations offered the new Chinese Republic a huge loan. Wilson’s “Moral” Diplomacy • In a statement issued soon after taking office, Wilson declared that the United States hoped "to cultivate the friendship and deserve the confidence" of the Latin American states, but he also emphasized that he believed "just government" must rest "upon the consent of the governed." Latin Americans were delighted by the prospect of being free to conduct their own affairs without American interference, but Wilson's insistence that their governments must be democratic undermined the promise of self-determination. • Moral Diplomacy was the idea that the United States would support only Latin American governments that were democratic or otherwise supported United States interests. Nicaragua • Troops still there from Taft’s presidency http://www.americanforeignrelations.com/OW/Protectorates-and-Spheres-of-InfluenceU-s-protectorates-prior-to-world-warii.html#b Haiti 1915 • Mob murdered their unpopular president. • US drafts a constitution for them. • Troops leave 1934. Virgin Islands • Danish West Indies were in danger of falling in the hands of the Germans, Wilson purchased them from the Denmark. Wilson and Mexico • When (1910) Mexico’s new leader (Madero) wasn’t nice to American business leaders. The US supported Victoriano Huerta’s govt take over (end of Taft’s term). • When Wilson took office (1913) Huerta’s new government murdered Madero. Wilson refused to recognize “Huerta’s government of butchers.” • Wilson then turned his support to Constitutionalists led by Venustiano Carranza. • Huerta sets up a military dictatorship. • In 1914 a few American sailors were arrested in Tampico and were shortly released. The Americans demanded a 21 gun salute as an apology. Mexicans refused and Wilson has the port of Veracruz seized. • Americans killed 126 Mexicans and 19 Americans died. • Carranza’s men captured Mexico City and Huerta fled the country. Wilson sent instructions on how to set up the new govt. Mexico refused to follow Wilson’s plan. • Wilson considers supporting Pancho Villa, but changes his mind in October 1915. • An angry Villa (feels betrayed) killed 16 American mining engineers that he took from a train in northern Mexico. (January 1916) • 2 months later he attacked Columbus, NM killing 17 more Americans. • Without Carranza’s permission John J. Pershing led an American Expeditionary Force to capture Villa. American ends up going to the brink of war. By March 17, 1917 Wilson withdraw due to larger problems.